Over the years TC have managed to apall and dissuade me from buying their records. This was the first of their 'Jumping on a train' moments, for me.
The inclusion of the Disintegration Extended mixes was a cop-out. And there was the diabolical requirement of purchasing the various singles to acquire all the 'new' mixes. Corporate sneaky.
I have no problem with Never Enough and sometimes I can enjoy the Red Mix of Primary.
The outtake of LGTB has some charm too. Though it came much later.
These days I have all the MU material gathered in one folder that is rarely looked at.
It would be so perfect If you would just fall out the window
There is a reason why I refer to Mixed Up as Messed Up. I (personally) find there's little enjoyment in hearing random people messing about with perfectly good tunes. My own view is that around this point in The Cure's timeline they had become suddenly fairly huge & this was something that was the product of that success. Robert always said around the time that he never wanted to be a huge star. But the momentum of Disintegration was something he couldn't really stop. It might be naff to some, but every step of The Cure's journey allowed new fans access to something they liked without fear of "gatekeepers" poo-pooing them. Something that often happens with bands. MU is probably one of those moments. I wouldn't describe it a naff. More experimenting to see what the future could possibly bring. But, yes. Jumping on a train could be implied. They also had to keep themselves on the radar fully in the knowledge that Disintegration was being lauded as some sort of Opus Dei & they had to follow that up with a new album that was at least as good, all the time keeping a growing legion of fans & music journos off their backs. I think MU was more of a shield than anything else.
Big fan of Mixed Up here, the cure were the kings of the 12 inch extended mixes, even the ones that didn't make the album like Close to Me (85 extended mix) and Boys Don't Cry (new voice club mix) sound great, bringing out new dimensions to the songs.
I'd even go as far as saying some of the extended mixes are the definitive versions for me. For example, Fascination Street (ext mix) blows away the album version imo.
Even when the songs were deconstructed and redone such as The Walk (everything mix), they came out so good. The Caterpillar (flicker mix) is so different to the original but is absolutely beautiful.
Just earlier today I was out with my headphones n MP3 player on shuffle and Friday I'm in Love (extended mix) came on and it was fukking fabulous.
Ok I'll admit I ain't keen on the mixes done externally where they take a line and repeat it ad nauseum like some of them circa WMS.
Last Edit: Mar 14, 2024 20:00:39 GMT 1 by mralphabet
There is a reason why I refer to Mixed Up as Messed Up. I (personally) find there's little enjoyment in hearing random people messing about with perfectly good tunes. My own view is that around this point in The Cure's timeline they had become suddenly fairly huge & this was something that was the product of that success. Robert always said around the time that he never wanted to be a huge star. But the momentum of Disintegration was something he couldn't really stop. It might be naff to some, but every step of The Cure's journey allowed new fans access to something they liked without fear of "gatekeepers" poo-pooing them. Something that often happens with bands. MU is probably one of those moments. I wouldn't describe it a naff. More experimenting to see what the future could possibly bring. But, yes. Jumping on a train could be implied. They also had to keep themselves on the radar fully in the knowledge that Disintegration was being lauded as some sort of Opus Dei & they had to follow that up with a new album that was at least as good, all the time keeping a growing legion of fans & music journos off their backs. I think MU was more of a shield than anything else.
I think it might have been also their way to do something playful after having done something serious and gloomy, in a similar way to how they followed up Pornography with Japanese Whispers.
In both cases, there might have been the self-dissacrating need to tune down the aura of seriousness building up around them.
I remember reading that with Let's Go To Bed, especially, Robert was "trying to kill" The Cure, after the tensions of the Pornography tour etc.
With Mixed Up it probably wasn't that extreme, but I feel it was their way to say "don't take us too seriously".
Again, similarly, after Wish (and Friday Im in Love) made them even more of a stadium filling band, and more radio friendly (FIIL was they best ranked single in the charts if I remember correctly?), after some hiatus they came back with a "self-success-sabotaging" album (WMS) that said "who cares" in capital letters.
Last Edit: Mar 14, 2024 20:07:58 GMT 1 by thebighand
I'd even go as far as saying some of the extended mixes are the definitive versions for me. For example, Fascination Street (ext mix) blows away the album version imo.
Totally agree with you there. Also the Hot Hot Hot!!! extended mix. That was superb too