Well, I'm not sure there are any others, but last week I noticed one, after many many years of listening.
On "From the Edge of the Deep Green Sea", there's one time where the main guitar riff is played incorrectly. We could go and say "oh, what if RS wanted to play it that way on that particular time", but c'mon, it's cleary not the case. The thing is, the main guitar riff has 4 different phrases. They're all similar, but played with different notes (trying to describe it well for non-musicians). The riff is the one that starts at 00:46. Let's call the 4 phrases A B C and D. So that's how they usually go. But the first time the riff is played with the vocals (Every time we do this I fall for her), he actually plays A C C and D. A mistake that I made often while playing the song.
So yeah, it's not a big deal, but I found it very curious to "discover" that
Do you know of any other "mistakes" on the official recordings?
But the first time the riff is played with the vocals (Every time we do this I fall for her), he actually plays A C C and D. A mistake that I made often while playing the song.
Well, I'm not sure there are any others, but last week I noticed one, after many many years of listening.
On "From the Edge of the Deep Green Sea", there's one time where the main guitar riff is played incorrectly. We could go and say "oh, what if RS wanted to play it that way on that particular time", but c'mon, it's cleary not the case. The thing is, the main guitar riff has 4 different phrases. They're all similar, but played with different notes (trying to describe it well for non-musicians). The riff is the one that starts at 00:46. Let's call the 4 phrases A B C and D. So that's how they usually go. But the first time the riff is played with the vocals (Every time we do this I fall for her), he actually plays A C C and D. A mistake that I made often while playing the song.
So yeah, it's not a big deal, but I found it very curious to "discover" that
Do you know of any other "mistakes" on the official recordings?
Do you mean on the recorded version I'll assume? Must have a listen. I play piano no guitar but I know an A C D chord when I hear it.
Ok first of all there HAS to be minor chords in there. I suspect an Em or Bm or both. Not just A C D. So are you just talking about the A C D chords themselves? Second of all they don't sound like normal A C D chords. They sound suspended ( aka the third is omitted). Third do you mean the chord on the acoustic or the riff on the electric? Just asking.
The production on Wish is phenomenal, I think any mistake - no matter how small would have been eradicated. There are so many underlying guitar riffs, drum sequences, bass lines and keyboards - even added vocals on almost every track, with my new SACD Player and the AKG K801's I am hearing so much more! Out of all the albums, Wish seems to have been treated like a "baby", with kid gloves - the production is just immaculate.
Ok first of all there HAS to be minor chords in there. I suspect an Em or Bm or both. Not just A C D. So are you just talking about the A C D chords themselves? Second of all they don't sound like normal A C D chords. They sound suspended ( aka the third is omitted). Third do you mean the chord on the acoustic or the riff on the electric? Just asking.
No no no, I was talking in non-musical terms, so non-musicians could understand. So I named the 4 phrases of the main guitar riff A B C D (maybe I should've gone with 1 2 3 4).
Musically speaking, the main guitar riff goes (from memory, might have some mistakes):
1.E D / 2.A F# / 3.G E / 4.B D
Those are single notes played, on electric guitar, not the acoustic guitar chords.
But on that first time he sings it, he plays
1.E D / 2.G E / 3.G E / 4.B D
I play this as a mistake sometimes because the bassline is a linear step up motion (E F# G A I think), so you end up thinking about the guitar line going linearly up too, but it goes up 1 - 2 then down 2 - 3 then up again 3 - 4.
You really think a pox would bother me?!?! I am immortal!! .............................. More importantly, I know where you both live so PFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFT!!